Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Honest Mary's Rewards

By frequenting Honest Mary's, you give our team the great joy of bringing life to your day on a consistent basis. Honest Mary's Rewards is a small way for us to say thank you for giving us this great privilege of serving you.

Frequently Asked Questions

What rewards platform do you use?

We are using Toast Rewards, which is fully integrated with our Toast POS (point of sale) system. In the past, we have used Fivestars.

I used to have a Fivestars account with you. Will my points transfer over?

Yes. If you've had a Fivestars account with us, we've automatically created a Toast Rewards account for you, as well as transferred the full value of your Fivestars points (from the time of the switch) over to Toast Rewards.

Click here to see if you already have an account setup, and to check the status of your points (rewards!).

Does it work with online ordering?

Yes. This is one of the great benefits of the switch. Now, when you order online via Toast Online Ordering, you can easily earn and redeem points.

How can I setup an Honest Mary's Rewards account?

Click here to setup your account. (Remember, if you've previously had a Fivestars account with us, then already setup a Toast Rewards account for you.)

How will points be added to my account when I place an order?

The system will primarily identify people for point earning & redemption through their phone number and/or email.

You also have the option to link your credit card to your account. This allows you to accrue points even when you're not signed into your Toast Online Ordering account. This also allows you to earn points in the store without entering your phone number.

How do I earn points & rewards?

You will earn 1 point for every $0.50 you spend. When you hit 100 points, you will receive a $3 discount that you can use towards paying for any item on our menu.

Is the point earning a better or worse deal than Fivestars?

Better. First, the total discounted amount of Toast Rewards is a bit more favorable than Fivestars. Second, points earned via Toast Rewards are essentially redeemed as dollars you can spend towards any item on our menu, as opposed to specific pre-determined items. Third, you can earn points when ordering online. Fourth, earning points is way more automatic than before, since your credit cards are linked to your account, and thus you don't have to enter your phone number every time.

If you have additional questions, simply email us at!